Gender a výzkum / Gender and Research 2023, 24 (2): 26-52 | DOI: 10.13060/gav.2023.014

‘Male and Female He Created Them’: The Roman Catholic Church’s Inconsistent Stance on Gender

Jiří Pavlík ORCID...
Univerzita Karlova, Husitská teologická fakulta

The article deals with the document ‘Male and Female He Created Them: Toward a Path of Dialogue on the Question of Gender Theory in Education’, published by the Congregation for Catholic Education in June 2019. The document is a guideline for Catholic schools, which they can apply to control and moderate the discussion on gender issues at the level of local churches and educational institutions. The article presents several worldwide responses to the document chiefly in the Catholic media, and then provides a rhetorical analysis and critique of its content. The analysis reveals some of the text’s rhetorical devices, including labelling, the self-referentiality typical of Church documents, and inconsistencies arising from attempts to balance its message, reflecting the conflicting loyalties of representatives of the church hierarchy since the Second Vatican Council. The article then carries out a more general critique of the Roman Catholic discourse on gender, which plays a significant role in fuelling the contemporary culture wars. This critique reveals the Church’s lack of self-reflection on its position and the arbitrary nature of its interpretations of gender related phenomena. Finally, it also highlights the political nature of the Church’s gender discourse, which seeks to uphold the status quo of the Church’s power structure.

Keywords: Catholic church, gender theory, anti-gender movement, ideology, heteronormativity, homosexuality, transgender, intersexuality

Received: March 11, 2023; Revised: November 22, 2023; Accepted: November 30, 2023; Published: January 6, 2024  Show citation

ACS AIP APA ASA Harvard Chicago Chicago Notes IEEE ISO690 MLA NLM Turabian Vancouver
Pavlík, Jiří. 2023. "‘Male and Female He Created Them’: The Roman Catholic Church’s Inconsistent Stance on Gender." Gender a výzkum / Gender and Research 24(2):26-52.
Share...
Download citation
  • BibTeX (.bib)
  • Bookends (.ris)
  • EasyBib (.ris)
  • EndNote (.enw)
  • EndNote 8 (.xml)
  • ISI WoS (.isi)
  • Medlars (.medlars)
  • Mendeley (.ris)
  • MODS (.xml)
  • Papers (.ris)
  • RefWorks (.txt)
  • RefManager (.ris)
  • RIS (.ris)
  • MS Word (.xml)
  • Zotero (.ris)
    • Open full article

    References

    1. Armstrong, P. M. 2019. 'Male and Female He Created Them' Rejects Gender Ideologies. NCR 11. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.ncregister.com/blog/male-and-female-he-created-them-rejects-gender-ideologies).
    2. Bachmann, E. 2019. U.S., English bishops welcome Vatican document on gender ideology. The Catholic Register 11. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.catholicregister.org/home/international/item/29707-u-s-english-bishops-welcome-vatican-document-on-gender-ideology).
    3. Baláž, P. L., M. Lajcha. 2018. Tragédie celibátu - mrtvá manželka. Martin: Kľak.
    4. Barberi, M. J., J. A. Selling. 2013. The Origin of Humanae Vitae and the Impasse in Fundamental Theological Ethics. Louvain Studies 37 (4): 364-389, https://doi.org/10.2143/LS.37.4.3047125. Go to original source...
    5. Bouma, D. 2019. Zpráva z konference: "Jako muže a ženu je stvořil (Gen 1,27)" (7. listopadu 2019, Katolická teologická fakulta, Univerzita Karlova, Praha). AUC Theologica 9 (2): 170-171, https://doi.org/10.14712/23363398.2020.15. Go to original source...
    6. Brown, P. (1988) 2000. Tělo a společnost. Muži, ženy a sexuální odříkání v raném křesťanství. Brno: CDK.
    7. Catholic News Agency. 2019. New Vatican Document Says Gender Theory Is 'Cultural and Ideological Revolution' (tisková zpráva). CNA 10. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/41503/new-vatican-document-says-gender-theory-is-cultural-and-ideological-revolution).
    8. Congregation for Catholic Education. 2019. 'Male and Female He Created Them': Toward a Path of Dialogue on The Question of Gender Theory in Education. Vatican City: Vatican Press. Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccatheduc/documents/rc_con_ccatheduc_doc_20190202_maschio-e-femmina_en.pdf).
    9. Congregazione per l'educazione cattolica. 2019. 'Maschio e femmina li creò': Per una via di dialogo sulla questione del gender nell'educazione. Città del Vaticano: Tipografia Vaticana. Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccatheduc/documents/rc_con_ccatheduc_doc_20190202_maschio-e-femmina_it.pdf).
    10. Cornwall, S. 2019. The Vatican's Male and Female He Created Them - A Response. The Shiloh Project 17. 6. 2019. Staženo 8. 2. 2023 (https://www.shilohproject.blog/male-and-female-he-created-them-a-response-to-the-vatican-report-on-gender-education).
    11. Corredor, E. S. 2019. Unpacking "Gender Ideology" and the Global Right's Antigender Countermovement. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 44 (3): 613-638, https://doi.org/10.1086/701171. Go to original source...
    12. Česká biskupská konference. 2022. Červená řada: dokumenty vydávané vatikánskými dikastérii. Staženo 17. 11. 2023 (https://cbk.cirkev.cz/dokumenty/dokument-c-45-jako-muze-a-zenu-je-stvoril_248).
    13. Čeští a moravští biskupové. 2018. Společný list biskupů českých a moravských diecézí ke schvalování tzv. Istanbulské úmluvy. Acta České biskupské konference 23: 365-367. Staženo 23. 5. 2023 (https://cbk.cirkev.cz/public/media/files/25/source/orig/24065_acta-cbk-2018.pdf).
    14. Čeští a moravští biskupové. 2023. Prohlášení ČBK k aktuálnímu dění ohledně manželství a rodiny 6. 7. 2023. Staženo 21. 7. 2023 (https://www.cirkev.cz/prohlaseni-cbk-k-aktualnimu-deni-ohledne-manzelstvi-a-rodiny_25218).
    15. DeBernardo, F. 2019. New Ways Ministry Responds to New Vatican Document on Gender Identity. New Ways Ministry 10. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.newwaysministry.org/2019/06/10/new-ways-ministry-responds-to-new-vatican-document-on-gender-identity/).
    16. Dever, R. 2019. The Vatican's New Document on Gender: Is There Hope? Association of Catholic Priests. 13. 6. 2019. Staženo 8. 2. 2023 (https://associationofcatholicpriests.ie/the-vaticans-new-document-on-gender-is-there-hope).
    17. Dicastery for Culture and Education. Documents of the Dicastery (The Section for Education). Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (http://www.educatio.va/content/cec/en/documents/documents-of-the-Congregation.html).
    18. Druhý vatikánský koncil. 1995. Dei verbum. Věroučná konstituce o Božím zjevení. Pp. 105-123 in Dokumenty II. vatikánského koncilu. Praha: Zvon, české katolické nakladatelství.
    19. Druhý vatikánský koncil. 1995. Gaudium et spes. Pastorální konstituce o církvi v dnešním světě. Pp. 179-265 in Dokumenty II. vatikánského koncilu. Praha: Zvon, české katolické nakladatelství.
    20. Foucault, M. (1984) 2003a. Dějiny sexuality II. Užívání slastí. Překlad K. Thein, N. Darnadyová, J. Fulka. Hermann & synové.
    21. Foucault, M. (1984) 2003b. Dějiny sexuality III. Péče o sebe. Překlad M. Petříček, L. Šerý, J. Fulka. Hermann & synové.
    22. František, A. Al-Tayyib. 2019. A Document on Human Fraternity for World Peace and Living Together. Libreria editrice vaticana. Staženo 9. 2. 2023 (https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/travels/2019/outside/documents/papa-francesco_20190204_documento-fratellanza-umana.html).
    23. František, A. Al-Tayyib. 2019. Documentum De Humana Fraternitate pro Pace Mundiali et communi convictu subsignatum a Summo Pontifice Francisco et Magno Imam al-Azhar Ahamad al-Tayyib Abu Dabi. AAS 111 (3): 349-356.
    24. František. 2013. Evangelii gaudium. AAS 105 (12): 1019-1137. Libreria editrice vaticana. Staženo 4. 3. 2023 (https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/apost_exhortations/documents/papa-francesco_esortazione-ap_20131124_evangelii-gaudium.html).
    25. František. 2015. Laudato si'. AAS 107 (9): 847-945. Libreria editrice vaticana. Staženo 4. 3. 2023 (https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/encyclicals/documents/papa-francesco_20150524_enciclica-laudato-si.html).
    26. František. 2016. Amoris laetitia. Radost z lásky. Praha: Nakladatelství Paulínky.
    27. František. 2020. Fratelli tutti. On fraternity and Social Friendship. Libreria editrice vaticana. Staženo 4. 3. 2023 (https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/encyclicals/documents/papa-francesco_20201003_enciclica-fratelli-tutti.html).
    28. General Secretariat of the Synod. 2021. Synodal Process. Synod 2021-2024. Staženo 27. 2. 2023 (https://www.synod.va/en/synodal-process.html).
    29. Grahn-Wilder, M. 2018. Gender and Sexuality in Stoic Philosophy. New Yoir, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. Go to original source...
    30. Greguš, J. 2019. Catholicism and Contraception. Česká gynekologie 84 (6): 468-474.
    31. Heroldová, M. 2018. Duka: Halík opakovaně napadá moje stanoviska, proto dostal napomenutí. Aktuálně.cz 20. 12. 2018. Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (https://zpravy.aktualne.cz/domaci/duka-halik-opakovane-napada-moje-stanoviska-proto-dostal-nap/r~cc8eaffc045911e9a446ac1f6b220ee8/).
    32. Honzejk, P. 2018. Piťhovo kázání o vládě homosexuálů byl agresivní bulvár. Církev se nemá chovat jako netolerantní sekta, říká kněz Petráček. Hospodářské noviny 1. 11. 2018. Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (https://archiv.hn.cz/c1-66320690-s-rozbehem-petra-honzejka-cirkev-se-nema-chovat-jako-sekta-hodne-katoliku-se-rozmysli-jestli-v-ni-jeste-zustavat-rika-teolog).
    33. Honzejk, P. 2019. Nacionalismus není cesta do nebe, ale do pekla, říká plzeňský biskup Tomáš Holub. Hospodářské noviny 9. 9. 2019. Staženo 8. 2. 2023 (https://archiv.hn.cz/c1-66636640-nacionalismus-neni-cesta-do-nebe-ale-do-pekla-rika-plzensky-biskup-tomas-holub).
    34. Hunter, D. G. 2015. Celibacy was Queer. Rethinking Early Christianity. Pp. 13-24 in K. T. Talvacchia, M. F. Pettinger, M. Larrimore (eds.). Queer Christianities. Lived Religion in Transgressive Forms. New York, London: New York University Press. Go to original source...
    35. Cheng, P. S. 2011. Radical Love: An Introduction to Queer Theology. New York, N.Y: Seabury Books.
    36. Intersex Human Rights Australia. 2019. Joint statement to the Congregation for Catholic Education. IHRA 17. 6. 2019, poslední aktualizace 16. 3. 2021. Staženo 8. 2. 2023 (https://ihra.org.au/35418/joint-statement-congregation-catholic-education).
    37. Jan Pavel II. 1994. Ordinatio sacerdotalis. AAS 86: 545-548.
    38. Jan Pavel II. 1997a. Ad Pontificiae Academiae Scientiarum sodales. AAS 89: 186-190.
    39. Jan Pavel II. 1997b. Laetamur magnopere. AAS 89: 819-821.
    40. Jones, K. J. 2019. Catholic 'Gender Theory' Document: Clarity for a Wounded, Oversexed Culture? The Catholic Register 11. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.catholicregister.org/home/international/item/29700-catholic-gender-theory-document-clarity-for-a-wounded-oversexed-culture).
    41. Katolická církev. 1995. Katechismus katolické církve. Praha: Zvon, české katolické nakladatelství.
    42. Kongregace pro katolickou výchovu. 2020. "Jako muže a ženu je stvořil": Cestou dialogu o otázkách genderu ve výchově. Praha: Sekretariát České biskupské konference. Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (https://cbk.blob.core.windows.net/cms/ContentItems/296_00296/jako-muze-a-zenu-je-stvoril-final-web.pdf).
    43. Kotrosits, M. 2015. Rethinking Early Christian Identity. Affect, Violence, and Belonging. Minneapolis: Fortress Press. Go to original source...
    44. Kuhar, R., D. Paternotte (eds.). 2017. Anti-Gender Campaigns in Europe: Mobilizing against Equality. London - New York: Rowman & Littlefield International.
    45. La Croix International. 2019. Vatican's new document on gender identity (tisková zpráva). La Croix International 11. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://international.la-croix.com/news/religion/vaticans-new-document-on-gender-identity/10299).
    46. Laqueur, T. (1990) 2017. Rozkoš mezi pohlavími: Sexuální diference od antiky po Freuda. Překlad M. Pokorný. Praha: Karolinum.
    47. Marchlewska, M., A. Cichocka, F. Łozowski, P. Górska, M. Winiewski. 2019. In Search of an Imaginary Enemy: Catholic Collective Narcissism and the Endorsement of Gender Conspiracy Beliefs. The Journal of Social Psychology 159 (6): 766-779, https://doi.org/10.1080/00224545.2019.1586637. Go to original source...
    48. McElwee, J. J. 2019. Vatican Office Blasts Gender Theory, Questions Intentions of Transgender People. National Catholic Reporter 10. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.ncronline.org/vatican/vatican-office-blasts-gender-theory-questions-intentions-transgender-people).
    49. Mickens, R. 2019. Vatican Document on Gender Is Like Lipstick on a Pig. La Croix International 14. 6. 2019. Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (https://international.la-croix.com/news/letter-from-rome/vatican-document-on-gender-is-like-lipstick-on-a-pig/10334).
    50. Mollenkott, V. R. 2001. Omnigender: A Trans-Religious Approach. Pilgrim Press.
    51. Nussbaum, M. 1999. The Professor of Parody. The Hip Defeatism of Judith Butler. The New -Republic. Staženo 4. 3. 2023 (https://newrepublic.com/article/150687/professor-parody).
    52. Nussbaum, M. 2022. Profesorka parodie. Módní defétismus Judith Butlerové. Překlad M. Kettner. Reflexe 62: 113-134, https://doi.org/10.14712/25337637.2022.19. Go to original source...
    53. O'Malley, J. W. 2015. Druhý vatikánský koncil: Humanistický koncil a řečová událost. Salve: Revue pro teologii a duchovní život 25 (4): 35-45.
    54. O'Connell, G. 2019. Vatican Issues New Document Criticizing 'Gender Theory'. America Media: The Jesuit Review 10. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2019/06/10/vatican-new-document-gender-theory).
    55. Pavlík, J. 2020. Tragédie církevní disciplíny aneb polemika nad "mrtvou manželkou". Studia Theologica 22 (2): 193-205, https://doi,org/10.5507/sth.2020.002. Go to original source...
    56. Pergler, T., T. Klézl. 2018. Spor Duky a Halíka se vyostřuje. Kardinál profesora pokáral kvůli Istanbulské úmluvě. Aktuálně.cz 11. 12. 2018. Staženo 6. 2. 2023 (https://zpravy.aktualne.cz/domaci/spor-duky-a-halika-se-vyostruje-kardinal-profesora-pokaral-k/r~36406e08fd6711e8a446ac1f6b220ee8/).
    57. Petro, A. M. 2015. Celibate Politics. Queering the Limits. Pp. 37-47 in K. T. Talvacchia, M. F. Pettinger, M. Larrimore (eds.). Queer Christianities. Lived Religion in Transgressive Forms. New York, London: New York University Press. Go to original source...
    58. Pavel VI. 1968. Humanae vitae. AAS 60: 481-503. Go to original source...
    59. Pius XI. 1930. Casti connubii. AAS 22: 539-592. Go to original source...
    60. Pius XII. 1950. Humani generis. AAS 42: 561-578.
    61. Pullella, Ph. 2019. Vatican Condemns Gender Theory as Bid to Destroy Nature. Reuters 11. 6. 2019. Staženo 7. 2. 2023 (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-vatican-gender-idUSKCN1TB20E).
    62. Rousselle, A. (1983) 1988. Porneia, On Desire and the Body in Antiquity. Transl. by F. Pheasant. Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock.
    63. Shaw, T. M. 1998. The Burden of the Flesh. Fasting and Sexuality in Early Christianity. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press.
    64. Schutz, P. J. 2019. A Response to the Vatican Document' Male and Female He Created Them'. National Catholic Reporter 24. 6. 2019. Staženo 9. 2. 2023 (https://www.ncronline.org/opinion/guest-voices/response-vatican-document-male-and-female-he-created-them).
    65. Synod of Bishops, XIV Ordinary General Assembly. 2015. The Final Report of the Synod of Bishops to the Holy Father, Pope Francis. Vatican City 24. 10. 2015. Staženo 9. 2. 2023 (https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/synod/documents/rc_synod_doc_20151026_relazione-finale-xiv-assemblea_en.html).
    66. Weekley, D. E. 2018. Becoming Grateful Allies: An Interview with Dr. Virginia Ramey Mollenkott. Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion 34 (1): 25-36, https://doi.org/10.2979/jfemistudreli.34.1.04. Go to original source...

    This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0), which permits non-comercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original publication is properly cited. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.


    Return to the content